Best Restaurants Near Broadway: Pre-Show Meals & Post-Show Bites

When it comes to finding the best restaurants near Broadway NYC, the choices can be dizzying. Whether you’re looking for near or a late-night indulgence after the curtain falls, we’ve got you covered with a guide to some of the best pre-theater restaurants in NYC.

New York City, with its hustle and bustle, is a mecca of tantalizing food options that cater to every palate. One area that stands out particularly is the famed Broadway district at the heart of the city renowned not only for its awe-striking performances but also for the diverse dining scenes.

The bustling area hosts an abundance of top-class dining establishments, providing a myriad of opportunities for both pre-show meals and post-show bites.

Whether you’re pining for an intimate dining room experience, a wine bar with an extensive wine list, or a place specializing in signature cocktails, there’s always a venue around the corner that offers exactly what you’re after.

Let’s embark on a culinary journey around Broadway and scour some of the best restaurants near me in NYC.

Map created using Wanderlog, a trip planner app on iOS and Android

Classic Favorites

Joe Allen

Open in Maps: 326 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

For over 50 years, Joe Allen has been a Broadway mainstay for both performers and fans alike due to its proximity to theaters. So if you’re in the Theater District, Joe’s will always appear when you search “places to eat near me.”

Best known for their signature cocktails and restful dining room, Joe Allen provides a warm, inviting setting to unwind before or after a show.

The menu, featuring American classics such as burgers, steaks, and a variety of lunch specials, is designed to satisfy a wide range of palates. This restaurant near Broadway offers an authentic New York City dining experience and stands as a testament to landmark Broadway eateries.

exterior view of the Joe Allen restaurant awning in Manhattan in NYC, New York, USA
photo credit: Joe Allen Restaurant via Facebook

Sardi’s

Open in Maps: 234 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036

Where to eat before a Broadway show? Located on 44th Street, Sardi’s is one of the best restaurants near Broadway and a popular pre-theater dining spot. The rich history of this timeless spot enhances the allure as you dine amongst the famous caricatures that fill the walls.

Related Post: Oldest Bars in NYC – Step Into History with NYC’s Age-Old Watering Holes

The menu features classic American and Italian cuisine, with options catering to a variety of taste buds. Whether it’s their tender Veal Scallopini or the homemade Cannelloni, Sardi’s makes every dining experience unique.

A favorite with locals and tourists alike, Sardi’s also offers a fabulous happy hour to add more joy to your Broadway outing.

Bar Centrale

Open in Maps: 324 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

Amid the bustling streets and bright lights of the Hell’s Kitchen, tucked away on a side street, you’ll find Bar Centrale, a gem hidden in plain sight. Here, you’re invited to enjoy a pre-show bite in a setting reminiscent of a cozy living room.

The restaurant is secretly tucked inside a brownstone building. With its low lights, vintage interior style, and comfortable couches, it offers an intimate escape from the city’s commercial bustle.

Their menu features a variety of delectable Italian dishes that will transport you straight to the vibrant culinary scenes of Rome or Tuscany.

Not to be overlooked is their refined selection of wines which perfectly complements any entrée choice or serves as an indulgent post-show treat on its own. Indulge in their signature cocktails during happy hour, or ask their knowledgeable staff for a recommended wine pairing.

Alcoholic Drinks

Trendy & Flavorful

Bond 45

Open in Maps: 221 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

Situated just a stone’s throw away from the Theater District, Bond 45 is known for its delightful delicacies and signature cocktails that would make any night out a memorable one. The dining room offers an intimate setting, promoting a cozy yet sophisticated vibe.

Related Post: Best Pizza NYC – A Delicious Foodie Guide

Whether you’re looking for ‘lunch near me’ or scouting the ‘best restaurants near Broadway NYC,’ the place provides a multitude of options to cater to distinct palettes – from mouth-watering antipasti to its famous mozzarella en carrozza.

To top it all off, their menu features an extensive selection of wines; a perfect ensemble to any meal. Bond 45 is undeniably a premium choice for a pre-theater meal.

Street view of the neon sign on the front of Bond 45 in NYC, New York, USA
photo credit: Bond 45 via Facebook

Los Tacos No. 1

Open in Maps: 229 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036

If you’re wondering about the best restaurants near Broadway NYC that offer a casual yet engaging dining experience, then you must visit Los Tacos No.1 on 43rd Street near Times Square.

It’s renowned for its robust menu featuring a medley of marinated pork, grilled chicken tacos, and of course, their notable queso taco.

The contagious energy of this place makes it a standout among other establishments in the Theatre District. Los Tacos No. 1, despite its simplicity, has gained recognition, including being awarded three stars in a review by Eater NY.

Close up photo of street tacos with lots of white onion
photo credit: Xavier crook via Facebook

Becco

Open in Maps: 355 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

Wondering where to eat before the Broadway show? Becco, perched comfortably on the renowned eateries street of 46th Street’s Restaurant Row, lures culinary aficionados seeking a taste of classic southern Italian cuisine.

The signature dish, ‘Sinfonia di Paste’ offers an all-you-can-eat pasta course rotating daily, rekindling the idea of grand family-style dinners.

Beyond pasta, Becco’s menu featuring items like Caciotta cheese ravioli or spicy lobster rigatoni alla vodka, fascinates with a variety of flavors. The extensive wine list pairs magnificently with the dishes, polishing the overall fine dining experience.

Well, deserving of the three stars awarded by Eater NY, Becco is a quintessential choice for theater-goers around Broadway, and those in search of ‘restaurants near me’ or ‘lunch specials near me’.

International Delights

Marseille

Open in Maps: 630 9th Ave, New York, NY 10036

Boasting of prime Broadway locale just beside 8th Ave, Marseille enchants patrons with its Southern French cuisine mixed with North African and Mediterranean influences. It’s a delight to dine here before your Broadway show, surrounded by the vibrant, vintage Parisian vibes.

Related Post: What to Do in Central Park – 19 Photo-Worthy Adventures for Every Season

They offer a pre-theater menu featuring a variety of signature dishes that ensure a quick, sumptuous meal. Pair your meal with their extensive wine list or sip on their uniquely crafted cocktails for an ideal start to your New York City night out.

Close up view of a sourdough pizza with tomatoes, cheese and spinach from Ops in NYC, New York, USA
photo credit: @opsnyc via Instagram

Donburiya

Open in Maps: 253 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019

Whether you’re searching for a spot for pre-show meals or an ideal destination for post-theater experiences, Donburiya should be on your list of must-visit restaurants near Broadway NYC.

This gem in the Theater District stands out for its extensive menu featuring classics like the Karaka Spicy ramen in a vegetarian broth and the tasty Karaage fried rice.

Savor their signature bowls of udon or try the Kaiseki Omakase for a special treat. For sushi lovers, dish selections like the Uni Sashimi and Oh Toro Sushi will most definitely delight.

Despite its quiet, understated exterior, Donburiya is a bustling treasure trove of authentic Japanese cuisine in the heart of New York City.

Lake surrounded by forest in Central Park - NYC, New York, USA
photo credit: Emily Kessler via Facebook

Elevated Experiences

Gabriel Kreuther

Open in Maps: 41 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036

With a menu featuring a fusion of Alsatian and contemporary French cuisine, Gabriel Kreuther’s Midtown fine dining restaurant here in New York City is a culinary masterpiece. Right on 42nd Street, this luxurious establishment is perfect for both pre-show meals and post-show bites.

Related Post: NYC Puerto Rican Day Parade – In-Depth Guide

Savour signature dishes paired with wines from their extensive wine bar, all while enjoying a view of the bustling 42nd Street. The intriguing blend of flavors makes Gabriel Kreuther an elevated choice among Broadway theatergoers.

Having been awarded three stars in a review by Eater NY, it’s clear why this spot has quickly become a favorite within the theater district (thus consistently earning a spot for best restaurants before Broadway shows).

Marea

Open in Maps: 240 Central Park S, New York, NY 10019

In the heart of New York City, within a stone’s throw of Broadway, sits Marea. This Michelin-starred restaurant offers more than just a beautiful view of Central Park.

The menu, featuring exquisite coastal Italian cuisine and top-grade seafood, includes classics such as their famous lobster and a wide array of signature cocktails.

Although it may be on the pricey side, Marea’s remarkable service, exceptional dishes, and elegant dining room provide an experience that is truly worth the splurge for a special dinner before the Broadway show.

FAQs About Where to Eat Before a Broadway Show

While Times Square offers convenience, venturing a few blocks away usually yields better quality food and a less touristy atmosphere. Explore the side streets of the Theater District or head towards Hell's Kitchen for a wider and more interesting Broadway restaurant selection.

Thankfully, many restaurants in the Theater District cater to post-show crowds with late kitchens. Classic spots like Joe Allen often stay bustling after curtain calls.

Brasseries and diners are also reliable bets and search online for specific restaurants near your theater with extended hours. Just search for "restaurant near me" and the open ones will come up!

NYC Broadway Discount Tickets

Want to make your Broadway trip even more memorable and budget-friendly? We’ve got just the solution for you. Consider booking your Broadway tickets on Tripster.

Aside from scoring discounted tickets, you also have the opportunity to bundle tickets to multiple shows for even more savings. There’s no better way to experience the excitement of Broadway on a budget.

Plan your theater excursion now and enjoy the best of Broadway, without breaking the bank.

What Did We Miss?

Do you have any additional tips or insights to share? Leave us a comment below!


Avatar photo

Written by Isis Maya Nissman

A New York native, Isis-Maya spent most of her professional life working in TV production until a vacation whisked her away to Central...


Have something to add? Post it here:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you a Tripster?

Create an account to get access to exclusive pricing and rewards.