Best Pizza NYC: A Delicious Foodie Guide

New York City may be a culinary wonderland, but we all know what food we really think of when this city comes to mind: pizza!

New York City is a mecca for pizza aficionados. It’s a place where the pursuit of the perfect slice becomes a way of life. From the golden, crispy edges of a thin crust pie to the daring, innovative toppings that would make any gourmet’s heart flutter, NYC pizza isn’t just food—it’s a cultural institution, a legacy wrapped in mozzarella and steeped in tomato sauce.

Think of this guide as your passageway through the aromatic alleys of coal fired oven sanctuaries and the hallowed halls of historic slice shops. These are the bastions where the legacy of Italian immigrants lives on. Their wood-fired delicacies not just surviving but reigning supreme in the fast-paced culinary scene of the city.

Now, get ready to embark on a savory expedition to explore the pizza parlors that have etched their names onto the gastronomic map, not just in New York, but across the globe. These are the places that turn a simple meal into a festive celebration of flavors. Where every bite narrates a story of tradition and innovation.

Joe’s Pizza NYC

Since its inception in 1975, Joe’s Pizza has become the gold standard for the best pizza in NYC. a true Greenwich Village hallmark where the art of the perfect New York slice is revered. This corner shop has become a culinary landmark, capturing the essence of New York’s pizza culture with its cash only, selling pizza by the slice approach.

The constant crowd, a blend of regulars and globe-trotting tourists, is a testament to the timeless allure of Joe’s thin crust pie—a masterpiece of crispy crust, vibrant tomato sauce, and just the right amount of melted cheese.

Joe’s Pizza NYC epitomizes the diversity of the Big Apple, presenting a slice as varied as the people who line up for it. More than just a pizzeria; it’s a place where the city comes together. Each bite from the renowned pizza place pays homage to the legacy of Italian immigrants and celebrates the unspoiled joy of a quintessential New York slice.

Close up of a cheesy pepperoni pizzaPaulie Gee’s

At Paulie Gee’s, nestled within the vibrant streets of the East Village, pizza is not just food—it’s a creative expression. This place is where the old-world charm of Italian culinary tradition meets a modern twist, creating a unique dining experience.

The pizzeria’s wood-fired ovens are the cornerstone of its mastery. Ensuring every pizza has the iconic charred edges and a sublime balance between a crispy bite and a tender chew. Here, the dough transforms into an artful base. Ready to be adorned with an array of gourmet toppings, from the sweet allure of hot honey to the robust homemade sausages bursting with flavor.

Related Post: Best Kid-Friendly Restaurants NYC: 12 Must Try in the Big Apple

Beyond just the inventive toppings, Paulie Gee’s commitment to quality and technique is evident in every slice. The carefully curated menu reads like a food lover’s fantasy, with each item promising a new adventure for your taste buds. The restaurant itself, a space that captures the essence of the East Village’s eclectic character, offers an atmosphere that’s as inviting as its dishes.

Patrons don’t just come here for the best pizza in NYC, but they also come for the experience—where the ambiance, the service, and the exquisite wood-fired pizzas combine to make Paulie Gee’s a destination that’s emblematic of the city’s dynamic food scene. Whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth, Paulie Gee’s ensures that each pizza is not merely eaten but savored as a culinary work of art.

Lombardi’s Pizza NYC

Lombardi’s Pizza in NYC is a place where they’ve been baking pizzas the same way since they started over a hundred years ago. Inside Lombardi’s, everything from the smell of the pizzas cooking to the old photographs on the walls tells the story of New York’s love affair with pizza.

The crust here is special – it’s crisp on the edges but still soft enough to fold, all thanks to the old coal ovens they’ve used since the doors first opened. The cheese melts just right, and the sauce, made with tomatoes and a mix of herbs, makes every pizza rich and full of flavor.

Every pizza at Lombardi’s is a nod to the city’s past, made with care and ingredients that stand out. Whether it’s the zing of spicy soppressata or the timeless appeal of pepperoni, Lombardi’s has a way of making each topping count, so every slice is delicious.

Exterior ground view of Lombardis Pizza in NYC, New York, USA
photo credit: New York – via Facebook

John’s of Bleecker Street

John’s Pizza on Bleecker Street in NYC is like a trip back to the 1920s. It’s a place that’s all about the classic New York pizza experience. When you walk in, you’re surrounded by old-school decor that takes you back in time. They’ve been making pizza the same way since they opened – by selling whole pies that are known for their great taste.

Related Post: Best Rooftop Bars NYC: 12 Stunning Must-See Skyline Views

The coal oven at John’s Pizza NYC is what makes their pizza special. It’s been around since the beginning, and it gives the pizza a smoky flavor and a crust that’s just the right kind of crispy. They stick to simple, good-quality ingredients, which is why people keep coming back. Even though New York City keeps changing, John’s Pizza is like a piece of history that stays the same, serving up slices that remind you of the good old days.

Little Italy Pizza NYC

Little Italy Pizza in New York City captures the spirit and flavors of Naples, thanks to the Italian immigrants who brought their pizza-making skills to the heart of the city. It’s a place that feels like a neighborhood corner of Naples, where the pizza is rich with authentic tastes and textures. The sauce on their pizzas is a tangy, herby concoction that coats the mouth with the flavor of sun-ripened tomatoes.

Their mozzarella is famously stretchy, pulling away with each bite in the most satisfying way, and it all sits atop a crust that’s been perfected to be crispy at the edges but soft and pillowy just where it counts. Think of it as a slice of Italian heritage served up right in Little Italy, NYC, perfect for anyone looking for a speedy lunch or a delicious dinner that reminds them of Italy’s storied pizza legacy.

So, whether you’re grabbing a slice on the go or sitting down to enjoy a meal, you can taste the care and history in every bite. Pizza enthusiasts will find joy in the consistent quality and the nod to Neapolitan pizza excellence that Little Italy Pizza provides. It’s a culinary landmark in NYC’s Little Italy, where every pizza is a celebration of Italian culture and the timeless art of pizza making.

Wide shot of pizzas on a display shelf in a restaurant
Photo Credit: Little Italy Pizza via Facebook

Louie and Ernie’s Pizza

In the bustling borough of the Bronx, Louie & Ernie’s invites you to fall in love with a slice of authentic New York pizza. The establishment lays down the groundwork with a dough that’s all about balance and soul.

Generous with their toppings yet never straying from the classic New York style, every pizza from Louie & Ernie’s delivers a crust that crackles just so, a sauce that’s lively and tangy, and a cheese pull that’s the stuff of Instagram legend. It’s the neighborhood gem that the whole city has come to celebrate.

L&B Spumoni Gardens

The Sicilian pies at L&B Spumoni Gardens are nothing short of a multisensory spectacle. Each pizza begins with dough that’s been allowed to rise to perfection, leading to a crust that’s undeniably crisp on the bottom while maintaining a fluffy softness within.

Related Post: New York City at Night: 42 Top Things to Do After Dark

The innovation of cheese beneath the sauce ensures each square slice is a decadent delight, and the vibrant, freshly spiced tomato sauce seeping into the airy dough creates a burst of flavor with every bite. L&B Spumoni Gardens, truthfully, is a destination where every square slice is a square meal and a slice of history.

Slice of pizza being picked up with a spatula off of a pan full of pizza slices
Photo Credit: L&B Spumoni Gardens via Facebook

Artichoke Basille’s Pizza

Artichoke Basille’s Pizza in NYC is a place where the simple pizza slice gets a big twist. They’re famous for their artichoke pizza – a rich and tasty mix of artichoke hearts, a creamy sauce, and lots of cheese on top of a crust that’s just the right kind of chewy and crispy.

It’s the kind of spot you have to check out if you’re looking for a pizza that’s a bit different and totally delicious. At Artichoke Basille’s, making pizza is about making something special and full of flavor, and that’s why people say it’s one of the best pizza places in the city.

Here, each pizza is made with care, and you can tell with every bite. They take the idea of an artichoke pizza nyc and add their own twist that makes it extra special. Whether you go for the famous artichoke pizza or try one of their other tasty kinds, you’re in for a treat. Artichoke Basille’s has made a name for itself as a spot where pizza is not just food – it’s an experience.

Wide shot of One World Observatory with Manhattan spreading out in the background

Your Saucy Sojourn Through NYC Awaits

This culinary journey across New York City isn’t merely a taste tour. Rather, it’s an expedition into the heart of New York City’s pizza heritage.

From the traditional East Side establishments to the modern innovators in the bustling streets, the best pizza NYC has to offer is a veritable mosaic of history, community, and unending love for the cherished slice.

And whether you’re a fan of drizzling your slice with a touch of olive oil, indulging in the sweetness of hot honey, or relishing in the simplicity of a traditional Sicilian pie, the city’s pizza scene caters to every preference. It’s as diverse and delightful as New York City’s own melting pot of cultures.

What Did We Miss?

Have a pizzeria to add to our list? Leave us a comment below!

Have something to add? Post it here:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are you a Tripster?

Create an account to get access to exclusive pricing and rewards.

Tagged in this post

New York City Restaurants