NYC Tourist Traps: Your Ultimate Guide to Dodging Tourist Pitfalls in the Big Apple
Hollywood paints New York City as a picturesque city where all your dreams come true.
There’s nothing quite like your first trip to New York City—until Elmo charges you $20 for a selfie and you realize that overpriced slice in Times Square tastes like regret. Welcome to the land of iconic landmarks and legendary New York tourist traps. If you’re not careful, you’ll blow your budget on fake tickets, microwaved pasta, and carriage rides that cost more than your flight.
But worry not: Tripster is here to help you navigate the NYC tourist traps like a streetwise New Yorker with a Yelp account and zero tolerance for nonsense. Whether it’s avoiding scams in Central Park, sidestepping the CD guy in Times Square, or finding that $8 pastrami sandwich that locals swear by, we’ve got your back.
So skip the stress (and the Elmo extortion) and get ready to explore New York City like a pro. This guide will help you enjoy the real Big Apple without getting peeled.
Classic NYC Tourist Traps to Avoid (and What to Do Instead)
Times Square Characters with Commitment Issues
They’ll wave you down in costume like they’re auditioning for Sesame Street, but the costumed characters in Times Square are running a whole other show. Take a picture and they’ll corner you for cash—sometimes aggressively, and often without warning.
If you must get a photo with Spidey, always agree on a tip first. They work in groups and can surround you fast, so keep it moving. It’s one of the classic tourist traps NYC throws at unsuspecting visitors. For a more chill experience, walk a few blocks to Bryant Park where the only thing performing is jazz on the lawn.
The “Free CD” or Monk Blessing Scam
Whether it’s a “free” rap CD or a bracelet from a robe-wearing monk, here’s the catch: it’s not free. They’ll hand it to you, bless your day, and then demand cash like it’s a holy invoice. The fix? Don’t take anything from strangers on the street, no matter how zen they look.
These scammers often hang around Times Square. and Union Square, so be extra alert in those areas. A polite “no thanks” and a confident stride can save you both money and hassle.
Chain Restaurants Near Major Attractions
Step away from that $29 chain burger at Rockefeller Center and no one gets hurt. These tourist traps in NYC are full of overpriced mediocrity. The food is usually pre-cooked, served slow, and priced like a fine dining experience without any of the flavor.
If you want a real NYC bite, head to neighborhood spots where chefs actually care about the menu. Try Joe’s Pizza, Los Tacos No.1, or Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop for better quality and local flavor.
Carriage and Pedicab Rides in Central Park
Yes, they look cute in Hallmark movies. But those carriage rides and pedicabs in Central Park are often overpriced and cover very little ground. Some charge by the minute, which means your romantic ride turns into a meter-running anxiety trip. Walk or rent a bike to explore the park on your own terms (and budget).
Skip the street haggling and get your Central Park experience the smart way—book with Tripster. We partner only with trusted vendors, so you know exactly what you’re getting before you step foot in the park; no sketchy pricing, no pressure, just smooth sailing (or biking).
Whether you’re renting a bike or joining a guided tour, Tripster gives you upfront prices, instant confirmation, and zero hidden fees. Why gamble with your wallet when you can book confidently and save?
Statue of Liberty Scammers at Battery Park
Outside Battery Park, fake ticket sellers will tell you the Statue of Liberty tour is sold out—but don’t fall for it. Buy tickets only from the official Statue City Cruises kiosk or online on Tripster. These scammers often wear uniforms and badges to look legit, but they’re not affiliated with any official service.
If you want to avoid the whole ordeal, skip the scammers and the stress with a faster, smarter option—Tripster’s Statue of Liberty Super Express Cruise. You’ll get up-close views of Lady Liberty and the Manhattan skyline without the crowds, the lines, or the headache.
It’s the perfect choice for travelers who want iconic views in record time, with instant confirmation and no surprise fees. Why risk a shady street pitch when Tripster gets you there faster and for less?
Sneaky NYC Tourist Mistakes Even Smart Travelers Make
Buying Souvenirs Anywhere But Chinatown
That single “I ❤️ NY” tee can cost anywhere from $11 to $20 in Midtown. But drop by Chinatown and you get THREE shirts for $10—same cotton, different zip code. Hit Canal Street for magnets, mugs, and merch without the markup.
You’ll find dozens of side-street stalls selling everything from snow globes to knockoff designer bags. It’s also a fun place to people-watch and grab a $2 pork bun while you shop. Just don’t be afraid to haggle, especially if you’re buying in bulk.
Sidewalk Stopping Syndrome
Locals walk fast. Like, late-for-a-job-interview fast. Stopping in the middle of a sidewalk to check your map or snap a pic is a classic tourist move, and mildly dangerous. Always step to the side or near a building before pausing.
Bonus tip: avoid standing at the top or bottom of subway stairs, you’ll be moved, physically or with stares.
Beat the Dealer Street Games
You didn’t suddenly become a card shark in the middle of SoHo. Those street games are scams with planted winners to lure you in. Once you bet, you lose—guaranteed.
Spotters in the crowd act as fake players to create hype and distract you while your money disappears. Save your cash for a Broadway lottery ticket instead, you’ll lose less and might even win big.
Sketchy Electronics Shops in Midtown
That off-brand camera lens for $500? Yeah, no. Many unmarked electronics stores in Midtown prey on tourists with inflated prices and shady return policies. They might offer a deal and then swap it for a different model after purchase.
Stick to big-name retailers like B&H Photo, Best Buy, or even local Apple stores. And always ask for a printed receipt—if they resist, that’s your sign to walk out.
Only Visiting Manhattan
We love Manhattan, but if you don’t venture into the other boroughs, you’re missing half the story (and most of the flavor). Hop the subway to Brooklyn and explore Pebble Beach, Prospect Park, and vintage treasures at Brooklyn Flea.
In Queens, hit Arepa Lady on Roosevelt Avenue for crispy corn cakes or grab Himalayan dumplings from Lhasa Fast Food, hidden inside a cellphone shop on 74th Street. Check out global art at MoMA, or a Mets game at Citi Field.
The Bronx offers old-school charm on Arthur Avenue (Little Italy’s real rival), plus wild encounters at the Bronx Zoo and history at Yankee Stadium.
Over on Staten Island, relax on South Beach, explore the Staten Island Greenbelt, or hit the Staten Island Museum—and yes, ride that iconic ferry for free. Each borough packs its own punch, and with just one MetroCard swipe, it’s like unlocking five adventures in one city.
Too Long, Didn’t Read? Here’s What Actually Matters
- Use official sources only: Buy your tickets on Tripster for upfront pricing and instant confirmation. Never trust street sellers, even if they’re flashing a “badge.”
- Set expectations before you snap: If you take a photo with a costumed character, agree on a tip in advance—or better yet, skip it.
- Never accept unsolicited items: CDs, “gifts,” and blessings handed out on the street almost always come with strings attached (and a cash demand).
- Watch out for time-based pricing: Pedicab and carriage rides often charge by the minute, not the ride. Always confirm the full price upfront, book online, or opt for a rental bike instead.
- Avoid impulse buys from shady shops: Electronics stores and souvenir stands near Midtown may inflate prices or swap products. Stick with trusted retailers and always get a receipt.
- Trust your gut: If it feels sketchy, it probably is. Confidently walk away and don’t let FOMO cloud your judgment.
Don’t Get Played in the Big Apple: Wrap-Up Time
Tourist traps in New York are everywhere, but with this guide, you’re dodging them like a cab in Midtown. From the photo-op hustlers of Times Square to overpriced pizza slices in Rockefeller Center, you now know exactly what to skip and where to go instead.
And whether you’re strolling Central Park on two feet (not four hooves), going ice skating in the winter, or finding souvenirs without blowing your Broadway budget, you’re officially traveling smarter.
Pro tip: You can even display your own photo or video on a Times Square billboard for 15 seconds every hour over a 24-hour period—just make sure to book it through Tripster for legit pricing and zero sketchy surprises.
Check out Tripster’s NYC Travel Guide for more legit tips, deals, attraction tickets (including the Empire State Building), hotel steals, show tickets, and vacation packages that actually get you places. Your wallet and your group chat will thank you.
New York Tourist Traps FAQs
Are the restaurants in Times Square worth visiting?
Not really. They’re mostly overpriced chains. Head to Hell’s Kitchen for better food and less drama.
Are there scams around major NYC landmarks?
Yes. Places like Times Square, Central Park, and Battery Park are hotspots for scammers offering fake tours or "free" gifts. Stick to official ticket booths and don’t engage with people aggressively pushing merchandise or services. If someone says a popular attraction is "sold out," double-check at the actual vendor. When in doubt, skip the street pitch.
How can a person avoid getting scammed when buying tickets for the Statue of Liberty?
Buy only from Tripster or the official kiosk at Battery Park. Avoid any street seller who claims the tour is sold out.
Is it a good idea to accept a "free" CD or bracelet on the street?
Absolutely not. It’s never actually free. Politely decline and don’t make eye contact.
Is the Museum of Modern Art worth visiting?
Absolutely—if you’re into iconic works and modern masterpieces. The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) houses works by Van Gogh, Warhol, and Picasso. It’s well-organized, centrally located, and often far less chaotic than other major tourist stops. Buy tickets online and go early to beat the crowds. Art nerd or not, you’ll leave inspired.
Should I tip street performers or subway musicians?
Only if you want to and genuinely enjoyed the performance. Many of them are incredibly talented, and tipping a dollar or two is appreciated. Just be cautious of performers who demand payment or pressure passersby. Watch from a distance first to see if it feels legit. You’re not obligated to tip unless it feels right to you.
How does a person use the subway without appearing to be a tourist or getting lost?
Download the map beforehand, avoid standing in doorways, and swipe your MetroCard like you mean it. Locals will respect the hustle.
Are there any street games to avoid?
Yes. If it involves money and a folding table, it’s a trap. Keep your cash and confidence intact—walk away.
Where is the best place to buy souvenirs?
Chinatown. The prices are lower and the variety is unbeatable. Skip the tourist shops near major landmarks.
